J.Crew Tilda Look-a-Like

Kohls | J.Crew I love J.Crew and don't usually cheat on them, but sometimes it's irresistible.  The 'Tilda' blouse was released this summer and I loved it, however sleeveless blouses just aren't versatile enough for my liking, especially to merit a $110 price tag.  Every time I got a sale e-mail I would add Tilda to my cart only to eventually remove her, and my self control paid off!  Kohl's came out with a pretty darned good reproduction WITH sleeves. Woohoo!   The only notable differences to me are:

• The sizing- the Kohl's blouse actually runs a little smaller than the J.Crew blouse (I wear a 2 in J.Crew and needed a 4 in this, 6 if I wanted it to be a little relaxed.)
• The Kohl's dupe doesn't have rhinestones all the way around the collar (about 4 inches in the back without them), which I actually prefer.  I find that my hair gets caught in the rhinestones, so I can only imagine what trouble having additional ones nobody could even see would cause.
• The Kohl's version does not have a very top button (visible in the J.Crew stock photo above).
• The Kohl's version has more stretch
• The quality isn't quite up to J.Crew standards, that being said, everything feels pretty sturdy and the blouse comes with extra buttons and rhinestones in a little baggie.
• The J.Crew blouse calls for dry cleaning, while Kohl's calls for hand washing or delicate cycle inside out (another win in my book).

Do you get excited about look-a-likes, or do you prefer to splurge on the real thing?  I'm usually a loyalist, but I couldn't pass up the sleeved version... I may have gotten all three colors.